Commercial Aircraft – General Aviation (private planes) – Helicopters accidents Though considered the safest mode of transportation, airplanes do crash.…
One of the best cruise ship accidents lawyers in Florida is the office of Leighton Law with over 37 years…
Traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) are extremely serious injuries that can affect victims and their families for a lifetime. A traumatic…
Miami car accident attorney John Leighton can help you with your claim Motor vehicle crashes continue to take over 40,000…
Catastrophic injuries are completely life changing injuries caused by another person or business. There are a lot of lawyers who…
Child sex abuse is a serious and persistent problem in our society. The frequency and long-term effects on children (and…
Construction accidents take lives and leave families devastated Accidents on construction sites or those caused by construction occur frequently. Because…
Legal malpractice occurs when a lawyer fails to properly represent a client. Just as a doctor may commit medical malpractice…
Medical malpractice involves medical mistakes by a health care provider, whether it is a doctor, hospital, nurse, dentist, medical/dental office…
Everyone claims to want to be Number 1, right? Well, Florida is Number 1…in motorcycle accident deaths.And Miami-Dade County is…
Negligent security cases involve someone who has been injured due to a violent or sexual crime. One way to reduce…
Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect Cannot Be Tolerated Patients in nursing homes or assisted living facilities deserve the highest level…
Parasailing and Water Sports Accidents The personal injury lawyers at Leighton Law have a long history of recovering some of…
What is “Personal Injury”? The field of personal injury involves many types of accidents and injuries. The one thing they…
Slip & Fall – Trip & Fall – Obstructions – Falling Merchandise When someone is injured from a slip and…
Defective or Dangerous Products Product liability means holding manufacturers and sellers responsible for products that injure or kill people. Florida…
Resort Torts (resort injuries) encompass almost every aspect of personal injury litigation. Resort Torts are personal injury cases for negligent…
1 out of every 6 women will be the victim of a rape or attempted sexual assault in her lifetime.…
Truck accidents and motor vehicle crashes continue to take over 40,000 lives each year due to: Distracted Drivers (DWD -…
Leighton Law is a personal injury and wrongful death firm dedicated to representing families of those who have been killed…
Reversing an appellate court which had upheld a motion to transfer the case to Mexico, Florida`s Supreme Court last week held that a case brought against a resort company which marketed to tourists to promote and sell timeshares at a resort in Mexico should not be dismissed.
In Cortez v. Palace Resorts, a woman was lured to a Mexican resort in an attempt to sell her a timeshare. As part of that inducement, the resort gave her a massage. During the massage, the masseuse sexually assaulted Cortez.
Cortez brought her case in Miami against three Florida businesses that all operated out of Miami. She claimed that the acts giving rise to her case, which included negligent vacation packaging, occurred in Miami. The trial court granted the defendants` motion to dismiss based on forum non conveniens, and Florida`s Third District Court of Appeal affirmed. In a dissent by Judge Rothenberg, she wrote that "The Florida defendants, with a straight face, claim that [Mexico] is a more convenient forum to litigate a United States Citizen`s negligent vacation packaging claim against them, although Miami is where their corporate headquarters is located…" The dissent went on to enumerate other factors in favor of keeping the case in Florida.
Cortez sought review by Florida`s Supreme Court, which on June 20, 2013 reversed the 3rd District and held that the trial court erred in dismissing the case. Finding that the 3rd District incorrectly applied the Kinney test [for forum non conveniens], and also ruled that the trial court erred in failing to give a strong presumption against disturbing the plaintiff`s choice of forum because she was a California resident. The Supreme Court held that the plaintiff`s residency in another state did not mitigate her right to have the strong presumption in her favor. The Supreme Court adopted much of the dissenting opinion.
According to the Court, Miami is the operational, managerial and marketing center for the entire Palace Resorts Group and is a proper place for the claims being asserted.
Cortez v. Palace Resorts, SC11-1908, June 20, 2013, further clarifies the Court`s prior holding in Kinney System v. Continental Insurance, 674 So.2d 86 (Fla. 1996), which was the Supreme Court`s prior pronouncement on the issue of forum non conveniens.
1401 Brickell Avenue, Suite 900 | Miami, FL 33131 . 121 South Orange Avenue, Suite 1270 | Oriando, FL 32801 | 888.988.1774